Sunday, January 29, 2023

We are the Water Protectors Review

-image from https://read.macmillan.com/mcpg/wearewaterprotectors/

1. BIBLIOGRAPHY: 

Lindstrom, Carole. 2020. WE ARE THE WATER PROTECTORS. Ill. by Michaela Goade. New York, NY: Roaring Brook Press. ISBN 978-1-250-20355-7

2. PLOT SUMMARY: 

With water as its focus, this story is told from a Native American naturalist perspective.  The narrator learns the importance of water from her grandmother, who tells her of the role water has played in nature and in their culture.  It is seen and valued as sacred.  The main character emphasizes the critical importance of water to man, animals, and nature.  Then an enemy of water is introduced as the ‘black snake.’  The illustration and description of the black snake infer it is an oil pipeline.  The story ends with the narrator standing against the black snake, as a guardian and protector of the water. 


3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS: 

This book speaks to an important environmental issue- the preservation and protection of water. Its symbolism of an oil and gas pipeline as a black snake is easily interpreted as an evil presence of destruction. It is social commentary through a simplistic perspective.  


It also highlights beautiful aspects of Native American culture, such as the respect and care of nature and the strong connections between familial generations. The relationship between the grandmother and granddaughter is strong and meaningful. It explores the role of stewardship of the earth. 


4. REVIEWS

Caldecott Medal, 2021
ALA Notable Children's Books, 2021
Booklist Starred Review, Feb. 1, 2020
"While the text draws on specific cultural beliefs, its argument is universal: "We are stewards of the Earth...A beautiful tribute and powerful manifesto."

5. CONNECTIONS

*This would be an excellent read aloud for the World Water Day on March 22nd or Earth Day, April 22nd.

*This book pairs well with Does Earth feel? by Majewski ISBN 978-0-06-302153-2

"This compelling narrative follows the planet's relationship with humans and engages with themes around empathy and environmentalism; a perfect book to spark conversations and inspire a new generation of young leaders." -from the publisher, Katherine Tegen Books

*We are Water Protectors Activity Kit by Carol Lindstrom



No comments:

Post a Comment

The Epic Fail of Arturo Zamora by Pablo Cartaya

  -from Penguin Random House This was a great book!  It is Realistic Fiction, and perfect for middle grade readers. It is set in sunny Flori...